Today a show’s nine-year reign over my heart as the best show ever ended.
I can hear your groans from here, but How I Met Your Mother started out as the promising show it grew to be in Seasons 1, 2, 3, 4, 5…and then it started wavering a bit. There was a lot of hits and misses for me after that, but what stayed constant and true was the hope and idea of true love that resonated with me in the protagonist, Ted Mosby.
Ted Mosby, I must admit, is not a likeable character. The first two seasons he was okay but then he got irritating. What got irritating was the fact he would always go back to Robin. I understand more than anyone that staying in touch with an ex is not always the best way to try and get over them. But it leaves you vulnerable to never changing and using that person as a “back-up plan”.
Now before I go on and ruin it for all you HIMYM fans out there I am warning you if you have not seen the finale yet and you don’t want to know what happens. DO NOT READ ON.
When Ted ended up with Robin my brain had to scramble to come up with conclusions to justify why I was so physically disgusted by this outcome.
My first conclusion was probably the most sane of the two. And it has to do with Robin being a “back-up plan”. In my mind Ted is so upset by his wife, Tracey, dying that he fell back on what was familiar and what had always been there for him. And that of course was Robin. I mean it makes sense, doesn’t it? Ted had loved Robin for so long and those feelings would have resurfaced after (what I assume) she had decided to pack it in and finally settle somewhere she was in constant contact with “the gang”. That makes sense right? RIGHT?!?
But then my second conclusion was just anger. Anger at the creators/writers for letting this happen to their show. I understand they had planned this ending years in advance, but they built this show on the idea of true love. They made us believe that NO ONE ELSE could compete with the mother. They built this ENTIRE show around how great she was and how she was the one for Ted. And through this made us believe that we were watching this show for a cause. But guess what? There is no cause. Just Ted, as always, thinking with his dick. It made you realise that all those years he spent growing as person to be worthy of the mother had just come undone in like four minutes. That’s all it took. It took you four minutes to realise that Ted is, and always will be, a fucking idiot.
Also I know there are some people out there who would have loved seeing Ted and Robin end up together. But let me say this. They’re no Ross and Rachel, from Friends. They never will be. It only worked with Friends because you were so emotionally invested in them. And that’s why I hated Ted and Robin getting back together because even though Carter Bays and Craig Thomas made us invest in the idea of Ted and Robin, they made us invest so much more in the idea of Ted and the mother. They cheapened their relationship by skimming over their emotional connections, the mother’s death and the aftermath. They cheapened Ted Mosby as a character and made him out to be someone who had probably killed his wife so he could conveniently get back together with Robin after all these years because he had loved her all along. Essentially Bays and Thomas made us feel like chumps – which I can never forgive.
The series finale of How I Met Your Mother was not legendary.
And today because of four minutes that was more disappointing than a man who comes early, it is no longer the best TV show ever.